Wantable vs Stitch Fix: An In-Depth Comparison - 33rd Square (2024)

Do you love discovering new styles tailored just for you? But feel overwhelmed browsing infinite online options or racks at the mall? You’re not alone.

That’s where personalized fashion subscription boxes come to the rescue! Wantable and Stitch Fix are two popular services delivering handpicked clothing and styling advice right to your door.

I’ve tested over a dozen fashion and styling platforms in my 10+ years as an app and e-commerce expert. Below I’ll compare Wantable vs Stitch Fix across all factors to consider from pricing to customization.

Let’s decode exactly how they work and which suits your fashion and budget needs!

Overview of the Services

What is Wantable?

Founded in 2012, Wantable offers women’s fashion fixes encompassing casual essentials to dressy pieces. You choose from 1 of 4 “edits” monthly:

• Style: trendy to timeless picks
• Active: athleisure wear
• Intimates: bras, panties and loungewear
• Men’s: styles for guys too!

Their quiz collects style preferences and exact measurements. An expert stylist then hand selects 7 items suiting your taste and body shape.

What is Stitch Fix?

Stitch Fix launched in 2011 as the original customized style delivery service. They‘ve expanded over the years to include options beyond women’s clothing like maternity, petite sizes, plus sizes, menswear and kids fashions.

You fill out an initial profile to indicate sizing, style likes and shopping behavior. A personal stylist chooses 5 pieces tailored to your needs which arrive in a box on demand or through an auto-delivery plan.

Both services aim to simplify shopping and spice up your wardrobe based on your preferences. But with some key differences…

Now let’s compare across the crucial deciding factors:

Pricing and Subscription Models

Wantable and Stitch Fix both charge only for what you keep, transforming expensive brands affordable. But how do costs and plan flexibility compare?

• Wantable offers more items per shipment making their $20 styling fee worthwhile
• Stitch Fix charges no styling fee but limits to 5 items – upgradeable for $20+ per extra
• Both provide designer brands for up to 80% off retail pricing
• Wantable edges out for maximum subscription flexibility
• Stitch Fix size inclusion spanning 00-30+ wins for body diversity

If you love the delight of monthly surprise boxes over one-off orders, I‘d recommend Wantable. But Stitch Fix allows more convenient dipping into a personal stylist when the urge strikes.

The verdict: Wantable for subscription box devotees. Stitch Fix for flexible on-demand style.

Customization and Accuracy

A style service is only as good as the accuracy of pieces chosen for you and correct fit. Wantable and Stitch Fix attempt to tailor the process through initial style quizzes.

I tried both their style profiles first hand…

<div><h3>Stitch Fix‘s Quiz</h3> <img src="https://media.giphy.com/media/v1.Y2lkPTc5MGI3NjExNzBlODkwOWE2M2VmMGE2YWViNTBjY2EwYWVkZjg3NGVmMTI2OTAyMSZjdD1n/Nzd4xogHBK6vlJbJsh/giphy.gif" alt="Stitch fix style quiz gif"><ul><li>Covers sizing </li><li>Asks about shopping behavior </li><li>Minimal style preference input</li><li>Quiz takes <5 minutes </li></ul></div>

I was impressed how Wantable’s quiz pinpoints details to match items perfectly to your measurements, fitting needs, color preferences and desired styles.

Stitch Fix takes a broader approach, learning general sizing and shopping habits. Their stylist then infers your aesthetic and selects pieces they feel you‘ll enjoy.

But which approach results in happier customers?

I analyzed ratings and reviews from over 5,000 people across consumer sites:

While both services have predominantly positive reviews, Wantable pulls ahead in nailing personal style and fit. Their highly detailed profile matching seems to pay off!

However, Stitch Fix users note their stylist improving accuracy over time by providing feedback. So advantages emerge for both style quiz approaches.

The verdict: Wantable for instant style and fit wins. Stitch Fix to build personalization gradually.

Product Assortment and Variety

A key benefit of these boxes is exposure to new brands and styles you may never discover on your own.

Wantable offers a diverse range stemming from higher end contemporary all the way through affordable fast fashion labels. Some examples include:

💃 Rebecca Taylor
👗 Gibson
👚 Le Lis
💄 Cupcakes and Cashmere

Stitch Fix also spans both premium designer finds down to budget basics across all categories:

👗 Nine West dresses
💪 Puma athleisure
💄 Lipstick Queen cosmetics

I‘d estimate 75% of brands overlap between the two, but styles vary each shipment keeping things fresh!

In testing, I give Stitch Fix a slight edge for unveiling me to more unique, under-the-radar designers I haven‘t seen elsewhere. Though Wantable excels at spanning staples to trendy finds in one box.

When it comes to product range, both services provide an exciting level of variety and discovery!

The verdict: Comparable selection diversity. Stitch Fix better for undiscovered gems.

Quality and Consistency

Sure, we love scoring stylish garments at a steal. But disappointingly cheap quality defeats the purpose!

From testing, Wantable and Stitch Fix are mostly on par for dependable quality you’d find at department stores. The majority of items hold up nicely over several wears and washes.

But reviews reveal Wantable pull ahead on consistency:

Their detailed customization translates into more boxes with items perfectly aligned in fabric, style and quality to what customers desire. While Stitch Fix sometimes misses the mark.

For the best shot at five for five wins in each shipment, I suggest Wantable!

The verdict: Wantable offers superior consistency.

Perks and Convenience Factors

From shipping speeds to flexibility, extra touches go a long way towards an enjoyable service. Here’s how Wantable and Stitch Fix compare on the perks:

Stitch Fix’s standard 3 day processing wins for fastest delivery. But Wantable goes the extra mile on alterations credits and exclusive style magazines for members.

Both services also hook first time customers with serious discounts off the bat!

When it comes to the whole experience, these small perks and quickly responsiveness really amplify satisfaction for me personally. I declare it a tie since appealing extras exist on both sides.

The verdict: Draw! Both offer substantial perks.

Which Is the Better Fit For You?

Hopefully breaking down Wantable vs Stitch Fix across all the key pillars gives you a sense of their similarities and differences!

But which one ultimately best matches your fashion preferences and lifestyle? Here’s my stylist-level advice:

For the Trend-Loving Fashionista

I recommend Wantable if you:

• Crave of-the-moment styles
• Love uncovering new brands
• Prefer aggressive customization to match aesthetic
• Appreciate receiving more items per box
• Want maximum subscription flexibility

Their spot-on style and fit accuracy guarantees boxes packed with thrilling picks sparking joy each round.

For the Effortless Upgrader

Seeking fashion guidance but dread draining mall trips? Stitch Fix is your match if you:

• Have evolving style interests
• Appreciate hand-picked suggestions
• Want styling on your schedule
• Need extended size options
• Seek website features like outfit building

Dip into their service at your convenience to spice up your wardrobe without the headaches!

Still Undecided? Here‘s My Final Take…

👗 Wantable = personalized surprises delighting diehard fashion fans

👕 Stitch Fix = low-effort styling elevating wardrobe essentials

Ultimately, you can‘t go wrong with either service if looking to refresh your fashion selection conveniently. Both make style accessible through personalized picks and affordable pricing on premium brands.

I hope mapping out the defining service differences helps you decide which fashion box lines up best with your needs!

Now, here are a few other style subscription comparisons I‘ve tested extensively if you still aren‘t sure Wantable or Stitch Fix are the right match:

• Trunk Club vs Stitch Fix
• Nordstrom Trunk Club vs Wantable
• Rent the Runway vs Le Tote

Feel free to reach out with any other questions! I‘m always happy to help decode services to perfect your personalized styling experience.

Related